SUBTRAÇÃO INTERNACIONAL DE CRIANÇAS E NÃO DEVOLUÇÃO FUNDADA EM VIOLÊNCIA DOMÉSTICA COMETIDA NO PAÍS DE RESIDÊNCIA
Abstract
Este estudo analisa a subtração internacional de crianças à luz dos casos de violência doméstica
perpetrados no país de residência habitual, com destaque para o papel da perícia psicológica
como garantia do melhor interesse da criança. O estudo conclui que a aplicação tradicional da
Convenção da Haia sobre os Aspectos Civis do Sequestro Internacional de Crianças nem sempre é
benéfi ca para as crianças subtraídas, especialmente em casos envolvendo violência doméstica ou
familiar.
Riferimenti bibliografici
BEZERRA, Daniela de Castro. Sequestro de crianças e Convenção de Haia: a violência doméstica
como hipótese de exceção de seu retorno ao país de origem. Londrina: Thoth, 2024.
BRONFENBRENNER, Urie. A ecologia do desenvolvimento humano: experimentos naturais e
planejados. Porto Alegre: Artes Médicas, 1996.
BRUCH, Caroline. The unmet needs of domestic violence victims and their children in Hague
Child Abduction Convention. In: Family Law Quarterly, v. 38 (2004), p. 529-545.
BURGESS, Melinda C. R. Race and gender stereotypes and violence and aggression. In: The
Wiley Handbook of Violence and Aggression, September 2017, p. 1-11.
COWAN, Philip; COWAN, Carolyn; SCHULTZ, Marc. Thinking about risk and resilience in
families. In: HETHERINGTON, E. M.; BLECHMAN, E. A. (Orgs.). Stress, coping and resiliency
in children and families. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum, 1996, p. 1-38.
DOUZENIS, A.; KONTOANGELOS, K.; THOMADAKI, O; PAPADIMITIOU, G. N.;
LYKOURAS, L. Abduction of children by their parents: a psychopathological approach to the
problem in mixed-ethnicity marriages. In: British Journal of Medicine & Medical Research, n. 2
(2012), p. 405-412.
EDELSON, Jeff rey; SHETTY, Sudha; FATA, Mary. Fleeing for safety: Helping battered mothers
and their children using Article 13 (1)(b). In: Research Handbook on International Child
Abduction, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 2023, p. 96-114.
FREEMAN, Marilyn; TAYLOR, Nicola. Domestic violence and child participation: contemporary
challenges for the 1980 Hague Child Abduction Convention. In: Journal of Social Welfare and
Family Law, v. 42, Issue 2, April 2020, p. 154-175.
FREEMAN, Marilyn; TAYLOR, Nicola. Where international child abduction occurs against a
background of violence and/or abuse. In: Research Report. Watford (England): International
Center for Family Law, Policy and Practice, April 2024, p. 1-90.
FREEMAN, Maerilyn. International child abduction: the eff ects. In: International Child Abduction
Centre, May 2006, p. 1-66.
GOODKIND, Jessica; SULLIVAN, Cris; BYBEE, Deborah. A contextual analysis of bettered
woman’s safety planning. In: Violence Against Women, n. 10 (2004), p. 514-533.
GRAHAM-BERMAN, Sandra; EDELSON, Jeff rey. Domestic violence in the lives of children: the
future of research, intervention, and social policy. Washington, D. C.: American Psychological
Association, 2001.
HCCH. Guide to Good Practice under the Hague Convention of 25 October 1980 on the
Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, Part VI, Article 13(1)(b). The Hague: HCCH
Permanent Bureau, 2020.
HOLT, Stephanie; BUCKELEY, Helen; WHELAN Sadbh. The impact of exposure to domestic
violence on children and young people: a review of literature. In: Child Abuse & Neglect, v. 32
(2008), p. 797-810.
HONORATI, Costanza. Protecting mothers against domestic violence in the context of international
child abduction: between Golan v. Saada and Brussels II-ter EU Regulation. In: Laws, v. 12,
Issue 5, Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca (2023), p. 2-20.
LINDHORST, Taryn; EDELSON, Jeff rey L. Battered women, their children, and international
law: the unintended consequences of the Hague Child Abduction Convention. Boston: Northeastern
University Press, 2012.
MASTERTON, Gina; RATHUS, Zoe; FLOOD, John; TRANTER, Kieran. Dislocated lives:
the experience of women survivors of family and domestic violence after being “Hagued”. In:
Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law, v. 44, Issue 3 (2022), p. 369-390.
MATTOS, Elsa de. A escuta de crianças nas perícias psicológicas de processos envolvendo a
Convenção de Haia sobre os aspectos civis da abdução internacional de crianças: relato de experiência.
In: GUIMARÃES, Lucas Dannilo Aragão (Org.). Avaliação psicológica em contextos
de pandemia. São Paulo: Editora CRV, 2022, p. 113-125 (Coleção Atualidades em Avaliação
Psicológica, v. 1).
MATTOS, Elsa de. Subtração internacional de crianças fundada em violência intrafamiliar: a
importância da aplicação do Protocolo de Julgamento com Perspectiva de Gênero. In: BARBOS,
Gabriela Jacinto; ELEUTÉRIO, Júlia Melim Borges; CASCAES, Luciana da Veira (Org.). Protocolo
de julgamento com perspectiva de gênero: refl exões, implementações e desafi os. Florianópolis:
Habitus, 2025, p. 123-138.
MAZZUOLI, Valerio de Oliveira. Curso de direito internacional privado. 6. ed. rev., atual. e
ampl. Rio de Janeiro: Forense, 2023.
MAZZUOLI, Valerio de Oliveira. Curso de direito internacional público. 16. ed. rev., atual. e
ampl. Rio de Janeiro: Forense, 2025.
MEIER, Joan S. Denial of family violence in court: An empirical analysis and path forward for
family law. In: GW Law Faculty Publications & Other Works, v. 110, 2021, p. 835-898.
MEIRA, Rodrigo Santos; MATTOS, Elsa de. Entre vozes e silêncios: a (não) participação das
crianças nos processos de subtração internacional envolvendo a aplicação da Convenção de
Haia de 1980 no Brasil. In: FARIAS, Inez Lopes Matos Carneiro de; SQUEFF, Tatiana Cardoso;
PALUMA, Thiago; MOSCHEN, Valesca Raizer Borges (Org.). Diálogos hermenêuticos entre
o direito internacional privado e o direito internacional público. v. 2. São Paulo: Tirant Lo
Blanch, 2024, p. 542-572.
MORLEY, Jeremy D. The future of the grave risk of harm defense in Hague International Child
Abduction Cases. The Matrimonial Stragegist, February 2007, p. 1-5. In: International Family Law,
New York, 2015. Disponível em:. Acesso em: 27 jan. 2015.
PELED, Einat; DAVIS, Diane. Groupwork with children of battered women: a practioner’s guide.
California: Sage Publications, 1995.
PÉREZ-VERA, Elisa. Explanatory Report: Hague Conference on Private International Law. In:
Acts and Documents of the Fourteenth Session (Child Abduction), tome III (1981), p. 426-473.
SANI, Ana I. Vitimação indireta de crianças em contexto familiar. In: Análise Social, n. 180
(2006), p. 849-864.
SHAKNES, Valentina; EDLESON, Jeff rey L. Protective measures and their inability to protect
against domestic violence. In: Hague Domestic Violence Forum, Expert Paper n. 5 (2024), p.
1-5.
SHETTY, Sudha; EDLESON, Jeff erson L. Adult domestic violence in cases of international
parental child abduction. In: Violence Against Women, n. 11 (2005), p. 115-138.
SPEARMAN, Kathryn J.; HARDESTY, Jennifer L.; CAMPBELL, Jacquelyn. Post-separation
abuse: a concept analysis. In: Journal of Advanced Nursing, v. 79(4), 2023, p. 1.225-1.246.
TAFÀ, Mimma; TOGLIATTI, Marisa Malagoli. Quando l’abuso psicologico è in agguato: la
sottrazione internazionale del minore – proposte operative. Maltrattamento e abuso all’infanzia,
v. 15, n. 2 (2013), p. 35-64.
TATLEY, Carolyn. Hague Convention: who is protecting the child? In: Children Australia, n. 37
(2012), p. 135-141.
TRIMMINGS, Katarina; MOMOH, Onyója. Intersection between domestic violence and
international parental child abduction: protection of abducting mothers in return proceedings. In:
International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family, v. 35, Issue 1, Oxford (2021), p. 1-19.
WEINER, Merle H. Answering Meier: family violence and the importance of primary prevention.
In: Virginia Journal of Social Policy & the Law, v. 30 (2023), p. 99-115.
WEINER, Merle H. International child abduction and the escape from domestic violence. In:
Fordham Law Review, v. 69 (2000), p. 593-634.
WEINER, Merle H. Intolerable situation and counsel for children: following Switzerland’s
example in Hague abduction cases. In: American University Law Review, v. 58 (2008), p. 335-
403.
WEINER, Merle H. Navigating the road between uniformity and progress: the need for purposive
analysis of the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction. In:
Columbia Human Rights Law Review, v. 33 (2002), p. 275-279.
como hipótese de exceção de seu retorno ao país de origem. Londrina: Thoth, 2024.
BRONFENBRENNER, Urie. A ecologia do desenvolvimento humano: experimentos naturais e
planejados. Porto Alegre: Artes Médicas, 1996.
BRUCH, Caroline. The unmet needs of domestic violence victims and their children in Hague
Child Abduction Convention. In: Family Law Quarterly, v. 38 (2004), p. 529-545.
BURGESS, Melinda C. R. Race and gender stereotypes and violence and aggression. In: The
Wiley Handbook of Violence and Aggression, September 2017, p. 1-11.
COWAN, Philip; COWAN, Carolyn; SCHULTZ, Marc. Thinking about risk and resilience in
families. In: HETHERINGTON, E. M.; BLECHMAN, E. A. (Orgs.). Stress, coping and resiliency
in children and families. New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum, 1996, p. 1-38.
DOUZENIS, A.; KONTOANGELOS, K.; THOMADAKI, O; PAPADIMITIOU, G. N.;
LYKOURAS, L. Abduction of children by their parents: a psychopathological approach to the
problem in mixed-ethnicity marriages. In: British Journal of Medicine & Medical Research, n. 2
(2012), p. 405-412.
EDELSON, Jeff rey; SHETTY, Sudha; FATA, Mary. Fleeing for safety: Helping battered mothers
and their children using Article 13 (1)(b). In: Research Handbook on International Child
Abduction, Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 2023, p. 96-114.
FREEMAN, Marilyn; TAYLOR, Nicola. Domestic violence and child participation: contemporary
challenges for the 1980 Hague Child Abduction Convention. In: Journal of Social Welfare and
Family Law, v. 42, Issue 2, April 2020, p. 154-175.
FREEMAN, Marilyn; TAYLOR, Nicola. Where international child abduction occurs against a
background of violence and/or abuse. In: Research Report. Watford (England): International
Center for Family Law, Policy and Practice, April 2024, p. 1-90.
FREEMAN, Maerilyn. International child abduction: the eff ects. In: International Child Abduction
Centre, May 2006, p. 1-66.
GOODKIND, Jessica; SULLIVAN, Cris; BYBEE, Deborah. A contextual analysis of bettered
woman’s safety planning. In: Violence Against Women, n. 10 (2004), p. 514-533.
GRAHAM-BERMAN, Sandra; EDELSON, Jeff rey. Domestic violence in the lives of children: the
future of research, intervention, and social policy. Washington, D. C.: American Psychological
Association, 2001.
HCCH. Guide to Good Practice under the Hague Convention of 25 October 1980 on the
Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction, Part VI, Article 13(1)(b). The Hague: HCCH
Permanent Bureau, 2020.
HOLT, Stephanie; BUCKELEY, Helen; WHELAN Sadbh. The impact of exposure to domestic
violence on children and young people: a review of literature. In: Child Abuse & Neglect, v. 32
(2008), p. 797-810.
HONORATI, Costanza. Protecting mothers against domestic violence in the context of international
child abduction: between Golan v. Saada and Brussels II-ter EU Regulation. In: Laws, v. 12,
Issue 5, Università degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca (2023), p. 2-20.
LINDHORST, Taryn; EDELSON, Jeff rey L. Battered women, their children, and international
law: the unintended consequences of the Hague Child Abduction Convention. Boston: Northeastern
University Press, 2012.
MASTERTON, Gina; RATHUS, Zoe; FLOOD, John; TRANTER, Kieran. Dislocated lives:
the experience of women survivors of family and domestic violence after being “Hagued”. In:
Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law, v. 44, Issue 3 (2022), p. 369-390.
MATTOS, Elsa de. A escuta de crianças nas perícias psicológicas de processos envolvendo a
Convenção de Haia sobre os aspectos civis da abdução internacional de crianças: relato de experiência.
In: GUIMARÃES, Lucas Dannilo Aragão (Org.). Avaliação psicológica em contextos
de pandemia. São Paulo: Editora CRV, 2022, p. 113-125 (Coleção Atualidades em Avaliação
Psicológica, v. 1).
MATTOS, Elsa de. Subtração internacional de crianças fundada em violência intrafamiliar: a
importância da aplicação do Protocolo de Julgamento com Perspectiva de Gênero. In: BARBOS,
Gabriela Jacinto; ELEUTÉRIO, Júlia Melim Borges; CASCAES, Luciana da Veira (Org.). Protocolo
de julgamento com perspectiva de gênero: refl exões, implementações e desafi os. Florianópolis:
Habitus, 2025, p. 123-138.
MAZZUOLI, Valerio de Oliveira. Curso de direito internacional privado. 6. ed. rev., atual. e
ampl. Rio de Janeiro: Forense, 2023.
MAZZUOLI, Valerio de Oliveira. Curso de direito internacional público. 16. ed. rev., atual. e
ampl. Rio de Janeiro: Forense, 2025.
MEIER, Joan S. Denial of family violence in court: An empirical analysis and path forward for
family law. In: GW Law Faculty Publications & Other Works, v. 110, 2021, p. 835-898.
MEIRA, Rodrigo Santos; MATTOS, Elsa de. Entre vozes e silêncios: a (não) participação das
crianças nos processos de subtração internacional envolvendo a aplicação da Convenção de
Haia de 1980 no Brasil. In: FARIAS, Inez Lopes Matos Carneiro de; SQUEFF, Tatiana Cardoso;
PALUMA, Thiago; MOSCHEN, Valesca Raizer Borges (Org.). Diálogos hermenêuticos entre
o direito internacional privado e o direito internacional público. v. 2. São Paulo: Tirant Lo
Blanch, 2024, p. 542-572.
MORLEY, Jeremy D. The future of the grave risk of harm defense in Hague International Child
Abduction Cases. The Matrimonial Stragegist, February 2007, p. 1-5. In: International Family Law,
New York, 2015. Disponível em:
PELED, Einat; DAVIS, Diane. Groupwork with children of battered women: a practioner’s guide.
California: Sage Publications, 1995.
PÉREZ-VERA, Elisa. Explanatory Report: Hague Conference on Private International Law. In:
Acts and Documents of the Fourteenth Session (Child Abduction), tome III (1981), p. 426-473.
SANI, Ana I. Vitimação indireta de crianças em contexto familiar. In: Análise Social, n. 180
(2006), p. 849-864.
SHAKNES, Valentina; EDLESON, Jeff rey L. Protective measures and their inability to protect
against domestic violence. In: Hague Domestic Violence Forum, Expert Paper n. 5 (2024), p.
1-5.
SHETTY, Sudha; EDLESON, Jeff erson L. Adult domestic violence in cases of international
parental child abduction. In: Violence Against Women, n. 11 (2005), p. 115-138.
SPEARMAN, Kathryn J.; HARDESTY, Jennifer L.; CAMPBELL, Jacquelyn. Post-separation
abuse: a concept analysis. In: Journal of Advanced Nursing, v. 79(4), 2023, p. 1.225-1.246.
TAFÀ, Mimma; TOGLIATTI, Marisa Malagoli. Quando l’abuso psicologico è in agguato: la
sottrazione internazionale del minore – proposte operative. Maltrattamento e abuso all’infanzia,
v. 15, n. 2 (2013), p. 35-64.
TATLEY, Carolyn. Hague Convention: who is protecting the child? In: Children Australia, n. 37
(2012), p. 135-141.
TRIMMINGS, Katarina; MOMOH, Onyója. Intersection between domestic violence and
international parental child abduction: protection of abducting mothers in return proceedings. In:
International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family, v. 35, Issue 1, Oxford (2021), p. 1-19.
WEINER, Merle H. Answering Meier: family violence and the importance of primary prevention.
In: Virginia Journal of Social Policy & the Law, v. 30 (2023), p. 99-115.
WEINER, Merle H. International child abduction and the escape from domestic violence. In:
Fordham Law Review, v. 69 (2000), p. 593-634.
WEINER, Merle H. Intolerable situation and counsel for children: following Switzerland’s
example in Hague abduction cases. In: American University Law Review, v. 58 (2008), p. 335-
403.
WEINER, Merle H. Navigating the road between uniformity and progress: the need for purposive
analysis of the Hague Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction. In:
Columbia Human Rights Law Review, v. 33 (2002), p. 275-279.
Pubblicato
11-05-2026
Come citare
de Oliveira Mazzuoli, V., & de Mattos, E. (2026). SUBTRAÇÃO INTERNACIONAL DE CRIANÇAS E NÃO DEVOLUÇÃO FUNDADA EM VIOLÊNCIA DOMÉSTICA COMETIDA NO PAÍS DE RESIDÊNCIA. Revista Do Ministério Público Do Rio Grande Do Sul , 1(98), 177-202. Recuperato da https://www.revistadomprs.org.br/index.php/amprs/article/view/462
Sezione
Artigos
